Broadband Speed Test: How To Estimate Your Real ADSL Speed
Is the speed showed by online tools truth?
I wanted to test my ADSL connection speed just for idle curiosity first and second to verify if I’m paying the right amount of money for all services on this line. As I am convinced that the experience is a good guideline for everyone, here you have a list of things you can do to test your home line speed.

For those less experienced I dare say that:
internet line can be compared to a sort of pipe and connection speed is the water passing from that pipe.
For this reason:
-
our provider doesn’t supply us with water but he just provides us with a pipe and we just pay for our pipe real capacities (the real amount of water that can pass through it);
-
the source of our water is not our ISP but it comes from another tab (the server we are connected to).
That is to say that all online programs measuring our line speed usually send us a file showing the download program speed (in practice they deliver into our tab a certain amount of water so that we can estimate the real quantity passing through our tab at the same time).
The first real trouble to run reliable tests is the following:
-
Is the speed showed by servers during these tests lie or truth? And is it the same one as for any pc? In other words, are the figures real ones?
-
If so, does this speed correspond to my computer one?
So you must check if the visualized download speed is not an invention.
To verify our speed we can install a program testing our band and it will show us the data entry speed that should correspond to the one visualized in any test site. I found a free and nice one, Netmeter. You can install and start it during your ADSL speed test so that you can do a comparison of all figures (the ones showed to you and also your pc ones). Then you will be showed a window like this one:

Make a supposition of your ADSL speed from different test results
It might even sound like a silly doubt, but it is not. In case my ADSL speed test server supplies my tab with a quantity of water smaller than its capacity, its speed will be a correct one but it will never correspond to my line real speed.
Here you have different download speeds reported during speed test programs I personally ran using these devices:
-
CPU dual core – WinXP Pro Notebook
-
Router Wifi Zyxel 660 HW
-
Wlan Connection 802.11 b/g (up to 54 Mbps)
| Adsl Speed Test | Kbps |
| Thinkbroadband | 1.161 |
| Zdnet | 4.492 |
| Bbmax | 2.338 |
| Speakeasy | 885 |
| Dslreports | 854 |
| Bandwidthplace | 908 |
| Myspeedtest | 1.750 |
| Visualware | 2.150 |
| Verizon.net | 536 |
| Broadbandchoices | 1.380 |
| Speedtest | 3.782 |
| Speedtest Libero | 3.143 |
| MClink | 3.547 |
| Cyclops | 3.662 |
Even if they are very variable, I had confirmation during all tests by my Net Meter that these data are reliable ones. So, how to know my real connection speed?
If thinking about the comparison of water and tab, with reliable figures, my ADSL speed nearest result certainly is the highest one (4.492 by zdnet.com.au). All the others had lower results for the following reasons:
-
They sent less data than my line could really support (less water than my tab capacities);
-
Maybe the net was engaged (a water waste during the flowing and so its incoming quantity is less than my tab capacities).
The main difference between Wifi and Ethernet cable connections
Of course, we are not dealing with the same 10Mbps I am paying money for, but I feel lucky in comparison to other people facing some sort of never ending stories. Anyway, I didn’t want to be content with that, so I had the care of repeating all tests again, this time connecting my notebook to the router by an Ethernet cable and not a Wifi connection.
Then a doubt arose, as I already knew that Ethernet cables guarantee a better performance on the same line in comparison to wlan 802.11 b/g, but I didn’t know how much.
Give a glance to all the same line and same conditions results, using an Ethernet cable to the router.
| Adsl Speed Test | Kbps (wifi) |
Kbps (cavo) |
| Thinkbroadband | 1.161 | 7.083 |
| Zdnet | 4.492 |
8.151 |
| Bbmax | 2.338 |
6.655 |
| Speakeasy | 885 |
4.030 |
| Dslreports | 854 |
3.328 |
| Bandwidthplace | 908 |
3.320 |
| Myspeedtest | 1.750 |
8.072 |
| Visualware | 2.150 |
7.441 |
| Verizon.net | 536 |
3.012 |
| Broadbandchoices | 1.380 |
4.093 |
| Speedtest | 3.782 |
7.029 |
| Speedtest Libero | 3.143 |
8.042 |
| MClink | 3.547 |
4.673 |
| Cyclops | 3.662 |
7.590 |
Connecting by a cable the notebook to the router, I obtained that my ADSL ran at an incredible higher speed! Then I had the possibility to confirm that all these tests are reliable even when new cable measurements show homogeneous and substantial differences among all ADSL speed tests in comparison to wireless ones.
I even had a strong waste of time trying to improve my wifi connection. I did so working on my router settings, but I didn’t get to any consistent improvement. Then, as for wireless connection, I was already in a sort of pole position.
Anyway, in this occasion too, I had the chance of making new discoveries, that sooner I’ll have the pleasure to share with you all.
Here the list of all Online Speed Tests
Here all links for speed test programs I used. They are in reliability level order:
- http://www.zdnet.com.au/broadband/speedtest.htm
- http://www.my-speedtest.com/
- http://assistenza.libero.it/angolo_pc/speedtest.phtml
- http://www.cyclops.it/ADSL/
- http://myspeed.visualware.com/uk/index.html
- http://www.thinkbroadband.com/speedtest.html
- http://www.speedtest.ch/it/
- http://www.speedtest.bbmax.co.uk/
- http://meter.mclink.it/applet.html
- http://www.broadbandchoices.co.uk/speed-test.asp
- http://www.speakeasy.net/speedtest/
- http://www.dslreports.com/speedtest
- http://www.bandwidthplace.com/
- http://infospeed.verizon.net/speedtest
How to estimate ADSL speed in a reliable way
In conclusion, there are few suggestions for running reliable tests:
-
Close any useless application for your test ( it could use up your band;)
-
Install on your pc a bandwidth meter to verify that all data, shown during test, are real ones;
-
Just use those programs that can support even higher speed (see upper list);
-
Always use Ethernet cables for your tests and never Wifi connection;
-
Repeat, for any program, your test more than once and in different hours, so to avoid any net saturation trouble (as I did when writing this article).
With all these new information you have a real idea about your tab reliability and, in case of complaining with your ISP, you will have all the data you need to support you.
Furthermore, it could even be fundamental to do this soon after a new line activation, keeping all data for a possible drop in speed performance as a consequence of an unlucky requalification for a duplex cable long-lasting use.
You should then send a mail complaint attaching all data you found before that requalification and asking:
“ If now my duplex cable is so used up it was supposed to be so even before, isn’t it?!”
Tags:
dsl
adsl
speedtest
broadband
check
internet
technology
tutorial
Daniele Di Gregorio